This is a Jacksonville FL real estate scenario that played out this week on our team:
- Jacksonville foreclosure property owned by Freddie Mac hit the market last week for $37,900.
- Our buyer offered $40,000, cash, two weeks to close. Did not ask for anything extra. Completely clean offer.
- Offer submitted to listing agent Friday to expire on Saturday. There was time to submit the offer before expiration.
- Agent confirmed receipt but did not submit to Freddie Mac prior to expiration of offer, instead held onto the offer, presumably to help solicit other offers.
- Late Monday we get a message that there are multiple offers and we need to submit our highest and best offer along with the Freddie Mac foreclosure multiple offer disclosure form.
- Tuesday we heard back that the offer would not be submitted without this form. The buyer was unavailable so we were not able to submit the form that simply said that we had to provide our highest and best by xx date and xx time, we understood there were multiple offers, blah, blah, blah. So from our understanding our buyer's offer was never submitted to Freddie Mac by the listing agent despite being submitted to the listing agent.
So How is Trying to Purchase A Jacksonville Foreclosure Like Playing Blackjack?
This scenario is not the least bit unusual for Jacksonville REO properties. This is the foreclosure game that you have to be aware of if you would like to pick up a foreclosure in the Jacksonville real estate market. You have to give it your best shot because you do not know what cards the dealer, (a.k.a. the listing agent") is holding. But just like blackjack you have to understand the odds are in their favor.
Are there REALLY multiple offers on that foreclosure you just placed a bid on?
Are we seeing multiple offers in this market? Absolutely! What are the odds that EVERY SINGLE foreclosure that we have a buyer bid on really has multiple offers? In our opinion the odds are not very high, yet this is the message we get on every foreclosure, with very rare exceptions.
It does not matter if it is the first day on the market or the 365th day there are almost always "multiple offers." Seriously. We've put in offers months after the homes came in the market and gotten this message. We've also put in offers HOURS after the Jacksonville home came on the market and gotten this message.
So if there are really a zillion offers on every foreclosure properties does that mean that Jacksonville foreclosures are underpriced?
The game is that the home is usually listed for less than it is worth in an attempt to solicit multiple offers and drive the price up over asking. This makes the listing agent look good for achieving multiple offers over asking price. This perception of a job well done occurs even if the home is dramatically underpriced in order to make it look like the home, and the agent, fetched a good price. In return that agent is rewarded with more listings.
Can I even GET a Jacksonville foreclosure?
Of course! If you are a Jacksonville home buyer looking to pick up an REO, work with an agent who knows how the system works. How bad do you want the property? Are you willing to walk away or do you feel like you absolutely have to have this home? This particular buyer wasn't willing to increase the offer on this particular unit based on the comps so it went to another buyer instead. Understand that the amount the home is worth is based on the CLOSED comparable sales for the past 3 months or so (as the market has continued to trend lower). Asking price is somewhat irrelevant if you want to buy a property. Make your offer based on what it is worth and your level of motivation and get geared up to play the game.